Top 10 Makeup Influencers in New York - Makeup Instagrammers in New York (2025)

Meet the top makeup Influencers in New York, well-recognized for their expertise, engagements, content excellence, strong brand alliances, follower numbers, average post likes. Check out who’s driving huge traffic on Instagram here!

Connect With Influencers

List of 10 Best Makeup Influencers on Instagram (2025)

@kristoferbuckle

1. @kristoferbuckle

353K Followers

Engagement Rate: 0.51%
Avg Reel Plays: 45.1K
Avg
Likes: 1.8K
Male Audience: 37.18%
Female Audience: 62.82%
@javonford16

2. @javonford16

282.1K Followers

Engagement Rate: 1.95%
Avg Reel Plays: 201.2K
Avg
Likes: 5.5K
Male Audience: 9.18%
Female Audience: 90.82%
@gucciwestman

3. @gucciwestman

373.1K Followers

Engagement Rate: 0.67%
Avg Reel Plays: 81.1K
Avg
Likes: 2.5K
Male Audience: 10.87%
Female Audience: 89.13%
@mcarecosmetic

4. @mcarecosmetic

302K Followers

Engagement Rate: 0.07%
Avg Reel Plays: 11.9K
Avg
Likes: 223
Male Audience: 3.06%
Female Audience: 96.94%
@ashleeholmes

5. @ashleeholmes

272.3K Followers

Engagement Rate: 0.66%
Avg Reel Plays: 38.6K
Avg
Likes: 1.8K
Male Audience: 4.51%
Female Audience: 95.49%
@katiejanehughes

6. @katiejanehughes

940.9K Followers

Engagement Rate: 0.73%
Avg Reel Plays: 181K
Avg
Likes: 6.9K
Male Audience: 2.98%
Female Audience: 97.02%
@melissamat_

7. @melissamat_

315.8K Followers

Engagement Rate: 3.17%
Avg Reel Plays: 155.5K
Avg
Likes: 10K
Male Audience: 4.43%
Female Audience: 95.57%
@briciaemilyn

8. @briciaemilyn

310.6K Followers

Engagement Rate: 0.80%
Avg Reel Plays: 46.8K
Avg
Likes: 2.5K
Male Audience: 7.35%
Female Audience: 92.65%
@cutcreaser

9. @cutcreaser

334.4K Followers

Engagement Rate: 1.76%
Avg Reel Plays: 49.5K
Avg
Likes: 5.9K
Male Audience: 6.02%
Female Audience: 93.98%
@cgonzalezbeauty

10. @cgonzalezbeauty

239.6K Followers

Engagement Rate: 1.04%
Avg Reel Plays: 34.7K
Avg
Likes: 2.5K
Male Audience: 20.55%
Female Audience: 79.45%

Get Insights of Top Influencers in New York

  • Access to 250,000+ Active Influencers on Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, Facebook, and LinkedIn
  • End-to-End campaign management
  • In-house creative team
  • Worked with 20k+ Brands
sony
Amazon
Puma